Making Mischief with Numbers
Jane Van Ryan
Posted May 10, 2010
The Center for American Progress (CAP) has posted a study on its Web site that could be one of the most misleading, stunningly incorrect documents posted online in months. It asserts that U.S. government energy data show "a large portion of the oil produced in the Gulf Coast region is actually exported to other nations..."
API economist Marcus Koblitz delved into the CAP study and found that the study's authors wrongly compared production of crude oil in the Gulf of Mexico to exports of crude oil and refined products from the nearby states-the areas where about one-half of U.S. refinery capacity is located. In other words, the authors compared apples to oranges and arrived at a completely nonsensical conclusion.
As Marcus explains, the refineries in the Gulf coast states (which make up the government's PADD III region) processed about 6.9 million barrels of crude oil a day in 2008, which is more than two-and-a-half times the amount of oil that was produced daily in the Gulf during the same time period. In fact, the government's data show that zero barrels of oil were exported in 2008 from PADD III.
So why would CAP produce such a flawed study now, as thousands of responders, many of whom are volunteers, are on the front lines with some of the best engineers in the world struggling to get the oil leaks stopped?
This isn't the time to use a drilling accident to push an agenda. And there's never a good time to distort the facts in an attempt to mislead the public.
Energy production in the Gulf of Mexico accounts for 30 percent of U.S. domestic oil production and 11 percent of U.S. domestic natural gas production. The United States needs all of the energy it can produce now and into the future. Government statistics show that the nation's energy demand is increasing, and oil and natural gas will play an important role in the U.S. energy portfolio for several decades into the future.
The facts are clear: Offshore energy development is essential to America's economy and energy security.
This post was informed by the following resources:
- EIA, "Exports: Crude Oil, Annual Thousand Barrels per Day"
- EIA, "Exports: Gulf Coast (PADD 3), Annual Thousand Barrels per Day"
- EIA, "Number and Capacity of Petroleum Refineries: Total Number of Operable Refineries, Annual"
- EIA, "Number and Capacity of Petroleum Refineries: Atmospheric Crude Oil Distillation Operable Capacity (B/CD), Annual"
- EIA, "Refinery Net Input: PADD 3, Annual Thousand Barrels per Day"
- EIA, "Crude Oil Production: Annual Thousand Barrels per Day"
- EIA, "Movements by Tanker and Barge between PAD Districts, PADD 3 to PADD X"
About The Author
- Blogger Conference Call - Oil Sands Development and the Keystone XL
- Blogger Conference Call - ExxonMobil Earnings and Taxes
- Blogger Conference Call - Industry Earnings and Public Pension Plan Ownership
- ETR 130 - The Oil and Natural Gas Industry's Contribution to State Pension Plans
- Keystone Pipeline: The Sooner, the Better
- Capping Stack: A Positive Outcome from a Tragic Accident